duanjiao6711 2017-08-04 21:34
浏览 209
已采纳

Golang:具有只读访问权限的包作用域变量是否需要互斥锁?

If I have a package-scoped variable like this:

var (
    bus *Bus // THIS VARIABLE
)

// Bus represents a repository bus. This contains all of the repositories.
type Bus struct {
    UserRepository *UserRepository
    // ...
}

...and I give access to the bus variable on my repositories so that they can access each other, do I need to use any sort of mutex if they can be used concurrently?

Quick pseudocode of what would happen:

// Router
router.GET("/user/:id", c.FindUser)

// Controller
func (c *UserController) FindUser(w http.ResponesWriter, r *http.Request) {
    w.Write([]byte(c.UserService.FindUser(r.Get("id"))))
}

// Service
func (s UserService) FindUser(id int) *domain.User {
    return s.UserRepository.FindByID(id) 
}

// Repository
func (r UserRepository) FindByID(id int) *domain.User {
    // This is where the package-scope `bus` variable will be used
}

In the FindByID function, I may use the package-scoped bus variable, which of course can be accessed concurrently since it will be called whenever an HTTP request triggers it, and those are all handled concurrently.

  • 写回答

1条回答 默认 最新

  • doujie9252 2017-08-05 00:47
    关注

    If all you do is reading the content of variable - then no, you do not need mutex. However, if you ever mutate its state, then you need to protect it.

    Two concurrent writes or concurrent write and read can cause problems. If your writes are rare, you might want to use RWMutex. It will allow multiple readers to access, but not together with a writer.

    Also, check out race detector. It is best effort detector, so it does not guarantee that you do not have race condition, but it can detect some use cases. Also note that you need to cause race in order for race detector to detect it, so writing tests that use your bus concurrently or simulating real conditions has to be done.

    本回答被题主选为最佳回答 , 对您是否有帮助呢?
    评论

报告相同问题?

悬赏问题

  • ¥60 补全networkx TODO部分。
  • ¥15 有内推吗,云计算linux运维方向
  • ¥30 sort cuteSV.vcf by bcftools用IGV可视化出现报错
  • ¥100 SOS!对STK中导出的天体图像进行质心提取有没有人做过啊
  • ¥15 python 欧式距离
  • ¥15 运行qteasy报错
  • ¥15 遗传算法解决有工序顺序约束的大规模FJSP问题
  • ¥15 企业消防水炮塔设计方案
  • ¥20 WORKBENCH网格划分
  • ¥60 急招师兄远程解决下载NPCAP的BUG!