指针上的golang指针作为函数参数

Question

I have the following function:

func addCatsToMap(m map[string][]CatHouse, meowId int, treats Set, dog *Dog) {

//if (complicated thing) add Cat to m

}

where Set, the type of treats, is an interface with the following definition:

type Set interface {
  Add(value string)
  Contains(value string) (bool)
  Length() (int)
  RemoveDuplicates()
}

Question:

Is it true that m, treats, and dog are passed-by-reference, and meowId has it's value copied?

I assume that:

• m is pass-by-reference because it's a map
• dog is a struct. So, I should pass the pointer to avoid copying the data

Answer 1

An interface type is simply a set of methods. Notice that the members of an interface definition do not specify whether or not the receiver type is a pointer. That is because the method set of a value type is a subset of the method set of its associated pointer type. That's a mouthful. What I mean is, if you have the following:

type Whatever struct {
    Name string
}

and you define the following two methods:

func (w *Whatever) Foo() {
    ...
}

func (w Whatever) Bar() {
    ...
}

Then the type Whatever has only the method Bar(), while the type *Whatever has the methods Foo() and Bar(). That means if you have the following interface:

type Grits interface {
    Foo()
    Bar()
}

Then *Whatever implements Grits but Whatever does not, because Whatever lacks the method Foo(). When you define the input to a function as an interface type, you have no idea whether it's a pointer or a value type.

The following example illustrates a function that takes an interface type in both ways:

package main

import "fmt"

type Fruit struct {
    Name string
}

func (f Fruit) Rename(name string) {
    f.Name = name
}

type Candy struct {
    Name string
}

func (c *Candy) Rename(name string) {
    c.Name = name
}

type Renamable interface {
    Rename(string)
}

func Rename(v Renamable, name string) {
    v.Rename(name)
    // at this point, we don't know if v is a pointer type or not.
}

func main() {
    c := Candy{Name: "Snickers"}
    f := Fruit{Name: "Apple"}
    fmt.Println(f)
    fmt.Println(c)
    Rename(f, "Zemo Fruit")
    Rename(&c, "Zemo Bar")
    fmt.Println(f)
    fmt.Println(c)
}

you could call Raname(&f, "Jorelli Fruit") but not Rename(c, "Jorelli Bar"), because both Fruit and *Fruit implement Renamable, while *Candy implements Renable and Candy does not.

http://play.golang.org/p/Fb-L8Bvuwj